John & John’s - A Pizza Shop

Karan Patel a month ago

As newcomers to the area, we weren’t sure what to expect, but John & John’s Pizza completely won us over! The pizza was absolutely delicious. It was fresh, flavorful, and as close to authentic New York style pizza as we’ve had in a long time. It honestly felt like we were back in New York. The customer service was just as impressive. Everyone was friendly, welcoming, and took the time to explain the menu and answer our questions. You can tell they genuinely care about their customers and take pride in what they do. We’ll definitely be back and highly recommend John & John’s Pizza to anyone looking for amazing pizza and outstanding service. Five stars all the way!

Jay 2 months ago

John & John’s is a must-try for any NYC pizza connoisseur in Orlando! The pizza was served piping hot and the crust was fantastic—exactly what you want from a fresh NY-style slice. Just a heads-up, the pepperoni slices are on the smaller side, which was a surprise since I prefer them a bit larger. Also, the dining area is very small and seating can be tough to snag. My recommendation? Order it to-go! The pizza stays incredibly hot, even for a long drive. Overall, really tasty pizza and I’ll definitely be back.

Matthew Garrepy 2 months ago

FINALLY… an NYC pizza joint that actually lives up to its promise of an authentic pie. Maybe one indicator is that it doesn’t promote itself as a New York slice, but the crust says it all: crispy in the right places, but totally foldable and delectable. John & John’s is an unassuming counter service establishment with no frills, but the staff was super attentive. Just a few tables inside and out, so a lot of takeaway - but we felt well taken care of. You can carry out, but I would recommend staying in and grabbing a can of Peroni. The pizza will make your toes curl, from a classic set of toppings to one of their specialties (like the blue cheese masterpiece). I can’t rave enough about the handhelds. The cheesesteak is AMAZING. They took Philly out of New York and exported it to Orlando. John & John’s is in the hip Michigan hood, so you could hit a few other bars if you’re still thirsty. Or just carry out and call it a night. Either way, this is an absolute find - and you won’t regret it.

Pete 3 months ago

As a native New Yorker, I'm always chasing a taste of New York City Pizza here in Orlando. This is not an easy thing to do as many shops are your classic conglomerate Pizza Hut, or Papa John's or Domino's. Even the local Mom & Pops are great for about a year and then they change management, cook or ingredients and everything falls apart. This is a great little shop, with fantastic pizza, great customer service, and a nice sit-down atmosphere that reminds you of an old diner. The pizza itself is delicious, the tomatoes are great, the cheese is delicious, my only complaint is that the crust is a little bit too crispy. When it gets a little bit too crispy kind of wanders into the territory of way to much crunch per bite. A New York Pizza should always have a crispy bottom, but the tip should always bend down when you hold it up, showing you that it's not overly crispy. Not to say it's not delicious. It absolutely is, especially compared to those chain restaurants. And the slices are a great size as well like NYC slices. The cheese itself is great quality, I wish you would pull a little bit more off on the bike, so you can get those strings of cheese coming off it like a classic New

Paul Wojcik 6 months ago

First timer at John & John’s Pizza. Very quaint atmosphere. Good seating inside and out and kid friendly. Had a delicious meal of 3 types of New York style pizza, Philly Cheese steak, Caesar salad and some escarole(Italian wedding) soup to start. Everything was fresh and tasty. Priced right for the quality pizza that we experienced. Great pizza place in the Sodo neighborhood. If you are looking for New York style pizza in Florida, John and John’s is your place. Try it.